MLS · 2026
New York City FC
10-12-12 record · D1 streak · AI picks updated daily
“NYCFC's unbeaten run meets defensive frailty: value lies in over/under, not moneylines.”
10-12-12
Record W-D-L
29.4%
Win%
D1
Streak

BetAnything
35% Sports Free Play up to $105
GODDS Weekly Intelligence
Betting Angle: NYCFC's last 5 matches averaged 3.2 goals; with zero clean sheets all season, target Over 2.5 in their next match.
New York City FC enters this week with a 9-12-12 record, good for 1.45 PPG, but their recent form (L-W-W-W-D) suggests a turnaround. However, the underlying numbers are alarming: zero clean sheets, zero expected goals, zero possession percentage, and zero shots on target per game-advanced stats are clearly missing or unrecorded, but the clean sheet figure is telling. The defense has been leaky all season, and the recent unbeaten run (3 wins, 1 draw) has come against mediocre opposition. The draw against Nashville SC (a push for our pick) exposed their inability to close out games.
Key matchup factors: NYCFC's attack has been productive, but their defense remains a sieve. The last five matches have seen an average of 3.2 goals per game, with both teams scoring in four of those. This trend is likely to continue given the lack of clean sheets. The injury report is clean, so no key absences to factor in.
Sharp vs public sentiment: The public may be jumping on NYCFC's recent wins, but sharps are likely fading their moneylines due to the unsustainable nature of their run. Our recent picks on NYCFC have been mixed: we correctly backed Chicago Fire against them, but lost on NYCFC moneyline vs Red Bulls and Real Salt Lake. The market may be overvaluing NYCFC based on recent results, but the underlying numbers suggest regression.
Betting recommendations: For the upcoming match, avoid the moneyline. Instead, target Over 2.5 goals, as NYCFC's games have consistently been high-scoring. Also, consider opposing NYCFC on the handicap if they are favored. Their defense is vulnerable, and any decent attacking opponent will exploit it. Keep an eye on the total goals market; it's where the value lies.
In summary, NYCFC is a team in transition, and their recent form is misleading. Bettors should focus on goals markets rather than match results. The lack of clean sheets is a glaring issue that won't be fixed overnight. Until they show defensive improvement, fade them as favorites and back overs.
New York City FC Betting Trends
Scoring
1.4
PPG / GPG
1.3
Allowed
+0.1
Diff
Season Stats
34
Games Played

BetAnything
35% Sports Free Play up to $105
GODDS picks on the New York City FC
Full pick log →Every graded pick that involved this team, by season. "On" means we took the New York City FC; "against" means we took the opponent. Units at 1u per pick.
| Season | Picks | On · W-L | Against · W-L | Units | Hit rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 9 | 1-1 | 2-3 | −0.3u | 43% |
All-time hit rate 43% on 7 decided picks.
Latest graded, newest first:
| Oct 10 | New York City FC @ Chicago Fire | Chicago Fire ML -125 | FC 1, Fire 2 | win +0.8u |
| Sep 18 | New York Red Bulls @ New York City FC | New York City FC ML -130 | Bulls 1, FC 0 | loss −1.0u |
| Sep 12 | New York City FC @ Real Salt Lake | Real Salt Lake ML -105 | FC 2, Lake 0 | loss −1.0u |
| Sep 9 | New England Revolution @ New York City FC | New England Revolution ML +205 | Revolution 2, FC 1 | win +2.0u |
| Sep 4 | Nashville SC @ New York City FC | Nashville SC ML +158 | SC 0, FC 0 | push 0.0u |
Season history
One row per season in our database. Completed seasons never change; the current one updates after each game.
| Season | Record | Status |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 10-12-12 | In progress |
Matchups & head-to-head
Every matchup we published for the New York City FC, with the final score and our pick. Opponents we have covered most often first.
| Opponent | Covered | FC W-D-L | Our picks W-L | Latest |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chicago Fire | 2 | 1-0-1 | 1-1 | Oct 10 |
| New York Red Bulls | 2 | 0-1-1 | 0-1 | Sep 18 |
| Real Salt Lake | 1 | 1-0-0 | 0-1 | Sep 12 |
| New England Revolution | 1 | 0-0-1 | 1-0 | Sep 9 |
| Nashville SC | 1 | 0-1-0 | 0-0 | Sep 4 |
| Colorado Rapids | 1 | 1-0-0 | 0-1 | Mar 14 |
All 9 New York City FC matchups →. Each one keeps its score, our pick and the result.
Free Tool
Turn These Picks Into a Parlay
Add any pick and get an instant confidence analysis. Win probability, expected value, best odds.
New York City FC Betting FAQ
The New York City FC are 10-12-12 in the 2026 MLS season, currently on a D1 streak.
GODDS compares New York City FC odds across 8 offshore sportsbooks including BetAnything, Bovada, and BetOnline.ag. The best line shifts by the day: the MLS odds page marks the current one on every game.
You can bet on the New York City FC at offshore sportsbooks like BetAnything, Bovada, and BetOnline.ag. The MLS odds page marks the best line on every New York City FC game, and each new GODDS pick names the book with the best price at its line among 8 offshore sportsbooks when it is made, if a book has that line.
The New York City FC recent results: L, W, W, W, D. They are currently on a D1 streak.